Somewhere in your business there are two or three people who, if they handed their notice in on Monday, would take the way the job is done with them. Every manager knows who they are. Few have a plan.
Here are the seven ways companies try to capture that knowledge, with what each one costs and what it misses.
1. Ask them to write it down
Free, and it almost never happens. Your best people are the busiest, writing is not their trade, and what they write tends to be the official version rather than what they do.
2. Shadowing and buddying
How most sites do it today. It works, slowly, and it copies the buddy's habits along with their knowledge. It also stops working the day the buddy leaves.
3. Exit interviews
Too late and too short. By the time someone is leaving you have an hour, and the person asking the questions usually does not know the job well enough to know what to ask.
4. Video the job
Useful for a visible, repeatable task. Useless for the decisions: why this setting, why that order, when to stop and call someone. The camera sees the hands, not the reasoning.
5. A consultant writes the procedures
Thorough and expensive, and the procedures are a snapshot. The day the consultant leaves, the drift starts again.
6. A knowledge management system
A place to put documents, with search. It solves storage, not capture. If nothing goes in, nothing comes out, and most of these systems are empty after a year.
7. AI interviews with everyone who does the job
Twenty minutes each, on a phone, in their own words, with follow-up questions that dig into the why. The answers are merged into a knowledge base and a procedure, every fact traced to a person, rebuilt as new people answer. Gaps and single points of failure are listed. It costs about the same as one consultant day a month per site.
| Method | Captures the reasoning | Covers everyone | Stays current | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ask them to write it | Rarely | No | No | Free, rarely done |
| Shadowing | Partly, by habit | No | Until the buddy leaves | Months of two salaries |
| Exit interviews | A little | Leavers only | No | Cheap, too late |
| Video | No | No | No | Cheap |
| Consultant | Yes, once | Sample | No | Five figures |
| Knowledge system | Only what is typed in | No | No | Licence plus discipline |
| AI interviews | Yes | Yes | Yes, with every interview | £1,500 a site a month |
The honest summary: the only methods that capture reasoning at scale are a consultant or AI interviews, and only one of them is still there next month.
See it with your own example. Thirty minutes with our team, using a question from your own work. Book a demo, or try the ROI calculator first.